| *Joseph Bryan | 1894-1908 |
| *James Alston Cabell | 1913-1929 |
| *Alexander Gustavus Brown, Jr. | 1929-1934 |
| *Herbert Worth Jackson | 1934-1937 |
| *Clifton Meredeth Miller | 1937-1940 |
| *Charles Russell Robins | 1940-1943 |
| *Otis Manson Alfriend | 1943-1944 |
| *James Pleasants Massie | 1944-1946 |
| *Herbert Worth Jackson, Jr. | 1946-1948 |
| *Thomas Callendine Boushall | 1948-1950 |
| *Wyndham Bolling Blanton | 1950-1952 |
| *Walter Spencer Robertson | 1952-1953 |
| *Samuel Merrifield Bemiss | 1953-1955 |
| *James Harvie Wilkinson, Jr. | 1955-1956 |
| *Edwin Hyde | 1956-1957 |
| *Samuel Spencer Jackson | 1957-1958 |
| *Lewis Franklin Powell, Jr. | 1958-1959 |
| *Edwin Cox | 1959-1960 |
| *Joseph Linwood Antrim, Jr. | 1960-1961 |
| *Lewis Garland Chewning | 1961-1962 |
| *William Fraser Tompkins | 1962-1965 |
| *William Ryland Gardner | 1965-1968 |
| *Osmond Tower Jamerson | 1968-1970 |
| *John Clifford Miller, Jr. | 1970-1972 |
| *James White Rawles | 1972-1974 |
| *St. George Tucker Grinnan, Jr. | 1974-1976 |
| *Catesby Brooke Jones, II | 1976-1978 |
| Cannon Hobson Goddin | 1978-1980 |
| *Herbert Worth Jackson, III | 1980-1982 |
| *Horace Hawes Harrison | 1982-1984 |
| *Russell Cecil Scott | 1984-1986 |
| *Edwin Cox III | 1986-1988 |
| *Burr Noland Carter, II | 1988-1990 |
| *Allen Mead Ferguson | 1990-1992 |
| *John Bruce James, Jr. | 1992-1994 |
| Miles Cary, Jr. | 1994-1996 |
| *Cyrus Barnholt Nicholas, Jr. | 1996-1998 |
| Douglas Pendleton Rucker, Jr. | 1998-2000 |
| *Roderick Dew Brown | 2000-2002 |
| John Bolling Williamson | 2002-2004 |
| *Robert Carter Brydon | 2004-2006 |
| Peter Edwin Broadbent, Jr. | 2006-2008 |
| *William Ramsey Richardson | 2008-2010 |
| Francis Claiborne Johnston, Jr. | 2010-2012 |
| Benjamin William Emerson | 2012-2014 |
| Henry Cannon Spalding, III | 2014-2016 |
| Lewis Taylor Cowardin | 2016-2018 |
| Charles Lewis Grant | 2018-2021 |
| Edward Dana Mitchell | 2021-2023 |
| Walter Jarvis Sheffield | 2023- |
| *deceased |
